Luxury Vinyl Flooring vs Carpet [2021]

Table of Contents

Pros of vinyl flooring vs carpet | Cons of luxury vinyl flooring vs carpet | Pros of carpet vs vinyl plank flooring | Cons of carpet vs luxury vinyl plank flooring | Which is better luxury vinyl flooring or carpet? | Which environment is suitable for carpet & luxury vinyl plank flooring? | How to clean carpet vs luxury vinyl plank flooring? | Luxury Vinyl Flooring vs Carpet Costs |

Luxury vinyl plank flooring comes in a variety of styles and textures. It is inexpensive and has many design options to choose from. Vinyl flooring can be installed fairly easily, without specialized skills.

Carpets also come in many different styles, designs, and textures, but they usually have a longer lifespan than vinyl flooring. Carpets are more expensive than vinyl flooring and require professional installation as well as specialized skillsets for any carpet repairs or cleanings.

Both carpeting and vinyl flooring are viable options when it comes to protecting your home from damage, but there are some pros and cons to weigh before deciding which one is for you.

Pros of Vinyl Flooring vs Carpet

– Easy to install without specialized skills or equipment.  You can install vinyl flooring yourself with a few simple tools and the right instruction manual.

– Vinyl floors are more durable than carpeting and they usually don’t show wear very easily.

– They come in many different colours, textures, patterns, as well as being easy to clean and maintain.

– Vinyl plank flooring are waterproof so you don’t have to worry about them getting damaged by water spillages or dirty footprints.

– Costs much less than carpeting if you hire a professional installer for both types of floor coverings (luxury vinyl flooring is also cheaper than laminate or hardwood floors). Even when comparing self-installation costs between vinyl flooring vs carpet, there is still a significant price difference.

– There are many styles and textures available for vinyl flooring, making it easy to choose a colour scheme or design that works with your home decor.

Cons of Luxury Vinyl Flooring vs Carpet

Negatively impacts the environment when compared to carpeting. Luxury Vinyl flooring needs an adhesive backing made from formaldehyde, which can be harmful to the environment if disposed of improperly. A lot of water is also used in manufacturing vinyl flooring.

Here is a list of potential cons of Luxury Vinyl Planks:

– Is prone to scratches and scuff marks. When installed incorrectly, this type of flooring isn’t very durable against heavy furniture being moved around on top of it too often and can easily show signs of wear after a few years depending on how well you take care of them

– Can be slippery compared to carpet flooring. Vinyl flooring can sometimes have a sheen to it that makes standing on it feel like you’re trying to walk on ice.

– Is hard and uncomfortable, making some areas such as kitchen/bathroom floors difficult to stand in for long periods of time.

– Vinyl planks are usually more expensive than carpeting. Because they are easier to install, they don’t require the same level of expertise when installed by a professional, so there is less markup in the cost of vinyl floor coverings compared with carpeting.

Considered more eco friendly than vinyl flooring but still uses solvents during the manufacturing process that can be harmful if disposed of improperly. Like vinyl flooring, it also requires adhesive backing that contains formaldehyde. Slip resistance needs to be added to carpeting using a separate treatment process that can make the price of carpeting more expensive than vinyl flooring in some cases.

Pros of Carpet vs Vinyl Plank Flooring

The biggest advantage of choosing carpet over vinyl is the fact it’s softer and feels better under foot, especially for any areas where you might spend a lot of time such as kitchens or bedrooms. It will also wear out much slower, which can help lengthen the life span of your home if properly installed and maintained. Carpet is also less likely to show scuffs and scratches unless there are significant damages to it due to how they are manufactured compared with vinyl flooring.

Most types of carpets are treated with stain-resistant during manufacturing so they are unlikely to stain or get damaged by liquids (unless extremely wet) and can be easily cleaned with a simple vacuum.  Vinyl floors will show signs of staining much more quickly, especially if you’ve got pets or children in your home who spill food on the floor frequently.

The biggest upside to choosing carpet flooring is that it’s treated during the manufacturing process with formaldehyde which makes it safer for people who have allergies to cope with around their house. It also releases less volatile organic compounds into the air when compared to vinyl flooring which reduces any adverse health effects caused by VOCs such as headaches and nausea.  

Cons of Carpet vs Luxury Vinyl Plank Flooring

Carpet does require professional installation because a proper installation is necessary to ensure it’s safe for people to walk on. In some cases using the wrong type of underlay and/or padding can cause carpeting to sag and become misshapen over time requiring expensive repairs or replacement.

It can also be a fire hazard if installed without adequate protection against spills, especially in kitchens where oil (from cooking foods) or grease (from deep-fried food) is commonly spilt onto the floor regularly.

Considered more eco-friendly than luxury vinyl planks but still uses solvents during the manufacturing process that can be harmful if disposed of improperly.

Like vinyl planks, it requires adhesive backing that contains formaldehyde which can potentially pollute waterways when not disposed of properly.

Slip resistance needs to be added to carpeting using a separate treatment process that can make the price of carpeting more expensive than vinyl flooring in some cases.

Which is Better Luxury Vinyl Flooring or Carpet?

vinyl plank flooring vs carpet

So as we have seen both types of floorings has its pro and con but as per value for money, it is better if you want your house to look good permanently then go with hardwood floors which are going to maintain their beauty for many years until you do anything wrong with them.

As these floors last up to 80 years or above so they will be there till your grandkids arrive at your age and pass on to them when the time comes.

Where the installation cost may seem like it’s too high initially, but when compared to replacing the carpet every time it gets old or worn out then you will find that hardwood floors are a great investment for your house.

Which Environment is Suitable for Carpet & Luxury Vinyl Plank Flooring?

In order to choose the best flooring with its consistent look and performance, there must be some factors we need to consider first like whether the environment where the flooring would be installed demands high quality of material or not, whether the price should also be considered as per affordability.

In addition, the material should be able to handle the toughest conditions; whether there are kids or pets who would use the floor on regular basis, sometimes it could get really challenging to maintain and clean.

In order to get a perfect answer for this question, first of all, we need to know about the materials of vinyl floors and carpet which will make me tell you here that they both are completely different types of materials. Vinyl flooring is manufactured from PVC (Polyvinyl Chloride) while carpets are made from wool, cotton and more commonly synthetic fibres such as polypropylene.

Carpet comes in many varieties including natural fibres where manufacturers combine them with artificial fibres such as nylon and fine yarns to make carpets look very appealing For durability, a carpet needs to be made with low-density fibres. Vinyl flooring on the other hand is designed for durability and you can find vinyl tiles that are suitable for commercial applications frequently.

No matter what type of material you choose, both will actually get dirty over time because they are regularly exposed to your foot traffic as well as your pet’s messes.

How to Clean Carpet vs Luxury Vinyl Plank Flooring?

A regular vacuum can clean up the dirt from either quite easily but it won’t completely remove tough stains or deep-seated dirt even if they are cleaned up so cleanup doesn’t remain an easy task resisting durable surface materials with wear and tear over the years.

But combining these two solutions will help you achieve more professional results; If you start using a better vacuum cleaner with better power as well as brush roll. Another solution you can use for both areas is by using a steam mop; it efficiently cleans and sanitizes your floors without applying any harsh chemicals in the process.

Carpet needs more care due to its properties which is associated with delicate fibres and materials, so while you are going to clean or treat them, make sure you have some protective gear on yourself like safety glasses.

Both these flooring types will need vacuuming regularly but be careful while cleaning up as they might get damaged if you scrub too hard.

In order to prevent that from happening buy a soft bristle broom that will not harm the surface material at all.  In addition, if there are carpet stains that do not come off then don’t use strong chemicals such as ammonia and bleach to clean it up, this will not be good for the carpet.

Treating your carpets using a deodorizer can make it smell nice but they are still exposed to damage. On the other hand, vinyl flooring is very simple to maintain since you just need to dust mop regularly so that it’ll help prevent dirt from being ground into the surface of the floor permanently.

The biggest difference between both carpet and vinyl floors is with their installation; Carpet needs professional installers who should lay down padding underneath before installing the actual carpet on top of that, while a quality Vinyl floor requires no padding at all which makes them much easier and faster to install than carpets for they are simple to remove. For luxury vinyl flooring, you can install them on your own but it will be better if you have someone’s help while installing the floor.

If you want both floors to last longer, then pay attention to the base itself & even potential the wear layer; make sure that you fix any damage as soon as possible because it might get worse in long run and end up costing more than expected.

For example, when there is a problem with the subfloor, such as cracks or holes check for mould problems below the carpet or vinyl flooring before tackling other problems and try to fix these first; this way will save you some money rather than going for unnecessary repairing later on.

Luxury Vinyl Flooring vs Carpet Costs

The cost of luxury vinyl flooring can be up to two times higher than carpets, however, prices may vary based on the provider. There are many benefits to vinyl floors that make it worth the cost. Vinyl floors offer a seamless surface that can be vacuumed without damaging the material.

They are easy to install and look great when installed correctly. Vinyl floors will not get dirt or grime trapped in the seam as carpet does. Unlike carpet, vinyl flooring is not vulnerable to mould growth. Vinyl has many benefits but they come with a hefty price tag.

Subscribe to our Weekly Newsletter

Related Resources

vinyl flooring vs floor tiles
Flooring

Vinyl Flooring vs Floor Tiles

The difference between vinyl flooring vs tile floors and what is best to choose. Here at Specifier, you can read about the pros and cons of both.

Stained Engineered Hardwood Flooring
Flooring

Engineered Flooring vs Floor Tiles

Discover the differences between floor tiles and engineered hardwood flooring to help your decide when is more suitable for your home or business